San Mateo Rental Car Accident Lawyer
Hit by a Rental? The Renter Doesn't Get a Pass.
Rental drivers are often unfamiliar with the car and the roads, and when they crash, the claim can get complicated fast. Our attorneys help people hurt in San Mateo rental car accidents identify who is responsible and pursue fair compensation.
$75+ million
recovered for injured clients
800+ five-star reviews
on Google and Yelp
No fee
unless we win
Available 24/7
Hablamos español · 한국어 상담 가능
Rental Car Claims Have Their Own Roadblocks
Rental cars are everywhere in California. Many of the people driving them are visitors or travelers who don’t know the vehicle’s controls, the local streets, or the traffic patterns. That unfamiliarity can lead to mistakes, and sometimes to serious crashes.
A rental car accident gives you the same right to compensation as any other auto accident. But it comes with a few extra problems to solve:
The rental company is rarely responsible for how a customer drives, so the claim usually runs against the driver
The renter may be from out of state, and may leave California before a claim is resolved
The renter may not be the person who was driving; someone the renter allowed to drive can be at fault too
Insurers on every side will argue that you were partly to blame
We know how insurance companies approach these claims, because our attorneys have worked with them for years. The consultation is free, and you pay nothing unless we win.
What to Do When a Rental Car Is Involved
Call the police to the scene.
A report ties the crash to a specific driver, vehicle, and rental company, which matters if the driver is heading home to another state.
Get the driver's home address and personal insurance.
Along with the rental company’s name and the car’s plate, ask for the driver’s own auto insurance and where they live.
Photograph the rental's paperwork if it's offered.
A rental agreement or company tag on the keys identifies the owner and the renter.
Note anything wrong with the rental car.
Warning lights, bald tires, or a driver who said the brakes felt off may point to a maintenance problem.
Get checked by a doctor promptly.
Treatment records link your injuries to the crash and protect your claim.
Call us before the renter leaves town.
The sooner we’re involved, the easier it is to locate the driver and secure their insurance information.
Who Can Pay After a Rental Car Crash
The rental's driver and their insurance
In most cases, the driver who caused the crash is the responsible party, whether they rented the car or borrowed it from the renter.
The rental company, in the right circumstances
When a company rents to an unlicensed or visibly intoxicated driver, or fails to maintain the vehicle and a mechanical failure causes the crash, it can be held liable.
Your own coverage
If the at-fault driver’s insurance falls short, your uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage may help close the gap.
The full scope of your losses
- Medical bills and future treatment
- Lost wages and reduced earning ability
- Pain, suffering, and emotional distress
- Vehicle repair or replacement
How We Handle Rental Car Crash Claims
Most rental car claims focus on one question: was the rental’s driver, whether the renter or someone they allowed behind the wheel, careless in a way that directly caused an otherwise preventable crash? We answer it with the police report, witness accounts, photos, and any available video.
Then we look past the driver. A rental company can be responsible in two narrow situations:
- It handed the car to someone unqualified, such as a person with no valid license or who was visibly drunk at pickup
- Poor maintenance caused a mechanical failure, and that failure directly caused the crash
We also prepare for the argument that you were partly at fault, and answer it with evidence. Every client gets a team, and you can text our main number for quick answers while your case moves forward.
California Law on Rental Car Accidents
Employers and rental companies are treated differently
When an employee crashes a company vehicle while working, the employer can be held vicariously liable under respondeat superior. A rental company is in a different position: once the rental period begins, it is rarely liable for the renter’s driving.
Negligent renting and poor maintenance are exceptions
A rental company can be responsible if it rented to someone it shouldn’t have, or if a maintenance failure directly caused the crash.
Your share of fault reduces your award
Under California’s comparative fault rule, you must be ready to show you weren’t partly responsible. Any fault assigned to you reduces your compensation by that percentage.
Two years to file
You generally have two years from the date of injury to file a lawsuit, and an out-of-state driver makes it wise to start well before then.
What Our Clients Say
This was my first time to have a car accident, so I did not know what I had to do. My friends suggested I contact Jimin since they all had…
Kwon Soonhyung
Jimin Oh is not only an excellent and professional lawyer but she is also very kind, understanding and easy to talk to. Jimin was very helpful and patient in answering…
Katie J.
Attorney Jimin Oh was really helpful with my case. She really took care of my case and I could really rely on her. She would always check up on me…
Carina Amigable
San Mateo Rental Car Accident FAQs
Can I sue the rental car company?
Usually not just because it owns the car. A rental company can be liable, though, if it rented to someone without a valid license or who was visibly drunk, or if poor maintenance caused a mechanical failure that led to the crash.
The driver who hit me lives in another state. Can I still recover?
Yes. An out-of-state driver can still be held responsible, and their insurance still applies. It does make acting quickly more important, so we can identify the driver and their coverage while the facts are fresh.
The person driving the rental wasn't the one who rented it. Who's responsible?
The person who was driving and caused the crash. A claim can proceed against a driver the renter allowed to use the car, as well as any insurance that covers them.
What if the rental car had a mechanical problem?
If a defect from poor maintenance directly caused the crash, the rental company may share liability. Tell us about any warning lights, noises, or comments the driver made, and we’ll look into the vehicle’s condition.
What if the rental driver's insurance isn't enough?
Your own uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage may cover the difference. We review every policy that could apply before you settle.
Can the insurer blame me for part of the crash?
It can try. Under California’s comparative fault rule, any share assigned to you reduces your award, which is why we gather evidence to show what really happened.
How much does it cost to hire you?
Nothing upfront. We work on contingency; you pay only if we recover compensation for you.
Get Your Free, Confidential Case Review, 24/7
A rental driver can be back in another state within days. Call now or send the form; we respond fast, 24/7, in English, Spanish, or Korean. Your consultation is free and confidential. No fee unless we win.
Call (408) 256-2871Free Case Review
Solution Now Law Firm
1253 Park Ave
San Jose, CA 95126
Hablamos español · 한국어 상담 가능
