Liability in San Jose Pedestrian Accident Cases
Being Badly Hurt Isn't Enough. Proving Fault Is.
Pedestrians suffer the worst injuries, but insurers don’t pay because of injuries alone. Our San Jose attorneys identify everyone responsible for your accident, and prove it.
$75+ million
recovered for injured clients
800+ five-star reviews
on Google and Yelp
No fee
unless we win
Available 24/7
Hablamos español · 한국어 상담 가능
Who Is Responsible Decides Whether, and How Much, You Recover
When a car hits a pedestrian, the person on foot almost always gets the worse of it. Yet that doesn’t mean a court or an insurer will automatically side with the pedestrian, even one with serious, life-changing injuries. Every pedestrian claim turns on one question: who was negligent?
Often the answer is simply the driver. But liability can be shared, and it can reach people who were never at the scene:
The driver who was careless or reckless behind the wheel
The driver's employer, if they were working at the time
A mechanic or parts manufacturer, if faulty brakes or a defect played a part
A property owner or government agency responsible for an unsafe sidewalk or crossing
Finding every responsible party matters, because each one may bring its own insurance to the table. And the insurer will try to add one more name to the list: yours.
How to Protect Your Claim When Fault Is Disputed
Make sure the police document the scene.
The officer’s report records positions, signals, and statements that are hard to dispute later.
Don't discuss fault with anyone but your lawyer.
Not with the driver, not on social media, and not with the driver’s insurer. Casual remarks become “admissions.”
Note anything that suggests another party.
A work vehicle or company logo, a rideshare sticker, broken pavement, a dead streetlight, or a blocked view.
Keep the evidence of a defect.
If the driver blamed their brakes or the car, tell us immediately; the vehicle itself may need to be preserved.
Photograph sidewalk and street conditions.
If you were forced close to traffic by a damaged or blocked sidewalk, capture it before it’s repaired.
Move quickly on any government claim.
If a public agency may share the blame, the claim generally must be filed within six months.
Who Can Be Held Liable for a Pedestrian Accident?
The driver
A driver who breaks a traffic law flagrantly and a driver who looks away for a moment are equally liable for the harm they cause. The severity of the mistake doesn’t change the responsibility.
An employer or vehicle owner
A driver on the job can make their employer responsible too, often with more insurance behind it.
A mechanic or manufacturer
If brakes failed or a part was defective, the shop that missed the problem or the company that made the part may share the blame.
A property owner or government entity
When poor sidewalk maintenance pushed you toward traffic, or a crossing or signal was unsafe, the responsible owner or agency may be liable. Government claims carry a six-month deadline.
How We Build Liability Against Every Responsible Party
We start where the evidence is freshest: the scene. Camera footage, signal data, witness interviews, and crash reconstruction establish what the driver did and whether they could have avoided you.
Then we look past the driver. We check whether the driver was working, whose vehicle it was, and whether a mechanical failure or defective part was involved. We inspect the sidewalk, crossing, signals, and lighting, and research who was responsible for maintaining them.
At the same time, we prepare for the insurer’s comparative-fault argument. If they claim you entered against a signal or stepped out suddenly, we test that claim against the evidence and work to keep any share of blame assigned to you as low as the facts allow.
How California Decides Fault in Pedestrian Cases
Liability starts with negligence
You must show that someone owed you a duty of care, breached it by failing to act as a reasonable person would, and caused your injuries as a result.
More than one party can share fault
Liability isn’t limited to one defendant. Each party that contributed can be responsible for its share.
Your own fault reduces, but doesn't bar, recovery
Under California’s pure comparative negligence rule, a court or insurer can reduce your compensation by your percentage of fault, for example for entering a crosswalk against the signal or stepping suddenly into traffic.
Deadlines differ by defendant
Lawsuits against a driver generally must be filed within two years; claims against a government entity within six months.
What Our Clients Say
I honestly recommend contacting the firm and working with Jimin. She was direct, very efficient, and professional. My case moved fast and to our favor. Jimin and her team were…
Ngan T.
She helped our family through the most difficult times we had ever gone through. When I wanted to give up she pushed us and encouraged us to keep fighting. When…
Beth S.
Attorney Jimin Oh was really helpful with my case. She really took care of my case and I could really rely on her. She would always check up on me…
Carina Amigable
Pedestrian Accident Liability FAQs
Isn't the driver always at fault when they hit a pedestrian?
Not automatically. Drivers usually are responsible, but you still have to prove negligence, and the insurer may argue you contributed. Strong evidence is what turns a serious injury into a successful claim.
Does it matter whether the driver was reckless or just careless?
Not for liability. A driver who makes a momentary mistake is as responsible for your injuries as one who flagrantly broke the law. Extreme recklessness can matter for punitive damages, though.
Can the city be responsible for my pedestrian accident?
Sometimes. If poor sidewalk maintenance, a dangerous crossing, or a failed signal contributed, a government entity may share liability. You generally must file a claim within six months, so talk to us quickly.
The driver says their brakes failed. Does that let them off?
Not necessarily. The driver may still be liable, and a mechanic who missed the problem or the manufacturer of a defective part may share the blame. Preserving the vehicle is key.
How does comparative fault affect my recovery?
Your compensation is reduced by your percentage of fault. Insurers use this aggressively in pedestrian cases, often without a court ever deciding it, so we push back with evidence.
What if the driver was working when they hit me?
Their employer may also be liable, and may carry more insurance than the driver alone. Tell us everything you noticed about the vehicle and the driver.
Can I recover if I was hurt on a sidewalk, not the street?
Yes. A driver who leaves the road, backs out of a driveway, or pulls out of a lot without looking can be liable, and so can a property owner if poor conditions played a part.
Get Your Free, Confidential Case Review, 24/7
The insurer has already started building its case about fault. Yours should start now too. Call or send the form; we respond fast, 24/7, in English, Spanish, or Korean. Your consultation is free and confidential. No fee unless we win.
Call (408) 256-2871Free Case Review
Solution Now Law Firm
1253 Park Ave
San Jose, CA 95126
Hablamos español · 한국어 상담 가능
